This week Haterade Hoops brings you our Top 5 NBA Players with guest writer Christian Bradley. Having another opinion really helped this story. Every time one of us made an argument for one player the other would counter and we’d end up going back and forth. Sometimes we budged. Other times we just agreed to disagree and understood the other writers point of view.
Haterade Hoops: I got Dwayne Wade #1 hands down and it ain’t even close—He’s got the ring, the insane dunks,the tremendous help D, the 1 on 1 ability and he shows up when it matters most. Yes, he did miss a year but he has had 3 seasons of 77 games played and after the Heat signed LBJ, Wade was clearly the true Batman of the two.
Christian Bradley: I had to go with the unpopular pick and say Lebron. He is in my opinion the most well-rounded player in the game, and, WHEN HE IS at the top of his game, he’s the toughest to guard in the league because of his combo of strength and athleticism.
Haterade Hoops: I agree with you in the LBJ is probably one of the toughest players to guard
in the league. I would like to see him post up more with his size and
athleticism. My biggest issue with LBJ is that he never shows up when it
matters most. He is Robin disguised as Batman. Wade has the ring and the
clutch gene you need to win.
Christian Bradley: Dwayne Wade– In terms of putting Wade at 2, if I can have any one player in the game for one single season, I have to take Lebron over Wade. Wade has the clutch
playoff performances, but I just can’t put shooting guard who is a historically
bad three-point shooter over a player like Lebron who does it all. Straight up looking at
the numbers, I can’t find another player in the league that adds more to a team
than Lebron.
Christian Bradley: I got Kobe at 3 but I’m curious about your thoughts on Durant and Rose, the two best young players in the NBA. Why Durant ahead of Kobe for you? I had Durant at #4 and Rose at #5
Haterade Hoops– #3 Kevin Durant . He is the most prolific scorer on the list and is a great leader. Rick Barnes is said to have been asked about his basketball team before KD arrived and he said he had the best player in all of college. The reporter asked don’t you mean freshman,
he responded no. The best player in college. KD had even played a game yet.He is getting better at
defense and led his team to the WCF last year. He is only 23 years old and has
yet to hit his prime. His size of 6’10 and the ability to play 2-4 is impressive. He hits clutch shots and will only get better.
Christian Bradley: Can’t argue with any of that, his ability to get to the free throw at what almost seem like will sometimes is just so impressive. My one knock on Durant would have to be that is three-point shooting has curiously gotten worse since he shot 42% from behind the arc in
08-09. He is still making outside shots in the high-30′s%, but I’m not sure he
is AS feared as he could be.
Haterade Hoops: Do you think that Durant’s drop in 3 point field goal percentage can be attributed to defenses learning how to defend him better?
Christian Bradley: I think if you look at our top 10, and have to pick one guy who has the potential
to be the best NBA player, it is Durant. The knock on him as a shooter is one
of the only knocks to choose from. Defenses focusing more on closing out on him
earlier I’m certain has a lot to do with it. But what I’m saying is with a continually improved outside shot, Durant has the talent to go down as one of the top players in the history of the game.
Christian Bradley : I had to put Rose in the top five when I did this, by far the best point guard in the game and he’s still just short of his 24th birthday. Scary.
Haterade Hoops: I think with the offensive talent or lack there of Rose has around him, he is relied on too heavily. Rose is the only that can carry the offense and it showed in the playoffs last year. Rose’s determination to get better ever year is only matched by the one and only Kobe. They said he needed to improve his jump shot, he did. Then they said he needed to improve his 3 point shooting, he did. Rose can play defense, rebound and isn’t afraid of the moment. I love the way this guy plays so fearless.
Christian Bradley: Absolutely, going from 22% from behind the arc his rookie year to 33% behind the arc last year is a clear sign of the work Rose puts in. He’s in unbelievable shape. I love
watching him in the 4th quarter of games because he just doesn’t tire.
Haterade Hoops: How about winning the MVP at 23 and terrorizing the league and being the only scoring threat on his team.
Christian Bradley :Honestly if you had put Rose at #1 or #2 I’m not sure how I would have argued. That Bulls team is one decent shooting guard away from a championship-Boozer has to stay healthy though. I think in the coming years Durant, Rose, and Griffin are probably just going to take turns winning the MVP award.
Haterade Hoops: Yeah well now that we have discussed it. I gotta put Rose 4. Kobe just got bumped.
Christian Bradley: A very agreeable move,the more we talk about Rose and Durant the more I want to put them at #3 and #4, respectively and bump Kobe to 5. Would you still keep Howard at #4?
Haterade Hoops: No. Howard or Kobe? Howard is younger has the defense but his offensive game has lacked for so long. His defense might sway me a little, but I think Kobe is till top 5
Christian Bradley: Agreed, I don’t think there is a more imposing post presence in the league than Howard, but I can’t possibly put him ahead of Kobe. Defensively, I love Howard’s game, but he has
no ability to score outside of 6-7 feet from the rim
Haterade Hoops: I think Howard needs to spend more time with the Dream. He is probably the most imposing post player since Shaq. But he lacks the domination that Shaq had
Christian Bradley: I’m glad you brought up Shaq because I feel like Howard’s high
school comparisons to Shaq are similar to Lebron’s high school comparisons to
Jordan. Whether the comparisons were fair is up for debate, but I think it’s
safe to say neither will live up to those monumental comparisons.
Haterade Hoops: Also, Howard’s his free throw shooting
is atrocious. He is a liability at the end of a game.
Haterade Hoops: So are we agreeing Kobe is still top 5?
Christian Bradley:Undoubtedly Kobe is top 5
Haterade Hoops: I agree, Kobe is still top 5. If I had to choose one player for one game, one shot. I want Kobe. Kobe’s ability to take over a game whether it be rebounding, defense or scoring. I think after his surgeries this year overseas, you will see the Kobe of 09 hoisting another Finals MVP. Kobe may never be Jordan but he’s the closest thing since.
Christian Bradley: Kobe is the closest thing we’re ever going to see to Jordan. Besides MJ, I’ve never seen a player play ith more intensity than Kobe, bar none.
Check back in next week as we discuss the bottom half of the top 10 NBA players.
Tell us what you think. Leave a comment.
Follow Haterade Hoops on Twitter @hateradehoops
Follow Christian Bradley on Twitter @chrisbradley13